m
Recent Posts
Connect with:
Monday / November 16.
HomeminewsOptometrist Calls for ‘Carol’s Law’ After Mother Killed by Vision-Impaired Driver

Optometrist Calls for ‘Carol’s Law’ After Mother Killed by Vision-Impaired Driver

A Brisbane-trained optometrist whose mother was killed by a driver with advanced age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is calling on the state government to introduce lifelong vision assessments for every licensed driver.

Under the proposed reform, named “Carol’s Law” in memory of the optometrist’s mother, drivers would have their vision assessed at set points throughout their lives. Under Queensland’s current rules, motorists under 75 can renew a private car licence without any check on their eyesight. 

The family started a Queensland Parliamentary e-petition asking for a legislative review of the state’s licensing rules. Members of the eye care community are being urged to sign it. 

“under the current honour system, there was nothing to stop him unless he chose to disclose it himself” 

A Preventable Death 

In 2020, Carol Ismail and her husband, Adam, were out on a Sunday morning bike ride, just minutes from their home, when a car struck them from behind. Ms Ismail did not survive. 

“My mother never came home. She was taken from us by a driver who was profoundly vision-impaired,” Ms Mc Donogh said. 

For nearly a decade, the driver had hidden his AMD diagnosis, and his medical unfitness to drive, from the licensing authorities. In that time, eye care professionals had told him explicitly and repeatedly that his vision loss left him legally unfit to drive. He was under 75, so his vision was never assessed, and he kept driving. 

The Director of Public Prosecutions first filed an indictment in the Brisbane Supreme Court for manslaughter by criminal negligence. The driver later pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death and was sentenced to six years’ imprisonment. 

The ‘Honour System’ 

The case has exposed what Ms Mc Donogh calls a fundamental weakness in Queensland’s licensing framework. Under the state’s “honour system”, the motorist is legally responsible for reporting a medical condition that affects ability to drive, to the Department of Transport and Main Roads (TMR). Drivers under 75 must self-report and are never checked. 

“Eye care professionals told this driver, more than once, that he could not legally drive, however TMR was not notified. Under the current honour system, there was nothing to stop him unless he chose to disclose it himself,” Ms Mc Donogh said. 

Modelled on the ACT 

Carol’s Law would bring in a universal, lifelong vision standard for driver licensing, based on the system used in the Australian Capital Territory. Vision would be assessed: 

  • when a person first applies for a licence 
  • at ages 50 and 60 
  • every five years from 60 until 75 
  • every year after 75. 

Ms Mc Donogh said the checks could be done during a routine eye examination. That would make them simple for motorists, and the assessment benefits would go beyond road safety. 

“This is a preventative model. As well as keeping unsafe drivers off the road, it allows for the early detection and management of eye disease, keeping the community safer and more independent for longer,” she said. 

How To Support The Petition 

To register a signature, practitioners and members of the Queensland public need to sign the e-petition through the Parliament of Queensland website and then verify their email address. Signatures that aren’t verified won’t be counted. 

The petition is available at: www.parliament.qld.gov.au/Work-of-the-Assembly/Petitions/petition-details/4736-26 

DECLARATION

DISCLAIMER : THIS WEBSITE IS INTENDED FOR USE BY HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS ONLY.
By agreeing & continuing, you are declaring that you are a registered Healthcare professional with an appropriate registration. In order to view some areas of this website you will need to register and login.
If you are not a Healthcare professional do not continue.